This is a very good point. Much is stuck on real/not real. It would make a better forum if there was a forum centred on "believers". I'm 100% sure it has been suggested. Do you know the reasons it was rejected? The other point is that really you need more than a forum. You need an organiser (somebody like Alex to take charge), a website (to record the "conclusions") and a forum (to generate the "conclusions") and a voting system. The site would be deeply influenced by the organiser but it would be better than nothing. I suppose, in a way, we have this. Alex has written his conclusions in his book and they are, to some extent, the conclusions of the Skeptiko community.